Breastfeeding may be a natural process, but it doesn't always come easily for every new mother. Nipple shields can be a valuable tool for overcoming challenges in the early stages, such as latching issues, soreness, or flat or inverted nipples. These silicone covers help babies attach to the breast more effectively and can alleviate pain for mothers. Here are some of the best nipple shields on the market, recommended by experts and tested by real parents:
1. Medela Nipple Shield
The Medela Nipple Shield is considered the best overall option by both What to Expect staff and community members. Available in three sizes (16 mm, 20 mm, and 24 mm), these shields are designed with a cutout for skin-to-skin contact, promoting a more natural feeding experience. The ultra-thin silicone is gentle on the skin and stays in place during feedings. A carrying case is included to keep the shields clean and hygienic.
2. Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield
The Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield is a popular choice, particularly for babies with tongue tie. The shield's lower profile accommodates a shallow latch, which can be a challenge for babies with this condition. Lansinoh shields are available in 20 mm and 24 mm sizes and feature a similar design to the Medela shields, but at a slightly more affordable price point.
3. Dr. Brown's Nipple Shields
Dr. Brown's Nipple Shields cater to mothers with larger nipples, offering sizes up to 25 mm. These shields are made of soft silicone and have additional holes at the tip to prevent milk pooling. While some users find the shape challenging for latching, they are a good option for those with larger nipples who need extended sizing.
4. Purifyou Nipple Shield
Affordability meets functionality with the Purifyou Nipple Shield. These shields are available in four sizes, including 16 mm and 18 mm, making them suitable for mothers with smaller nipples. The wide, curved design mimics the natural shape of the breast, helping the shield stay in place better. They also come with a carrying case and are one of the most cost-effective options on the list.
5. Haakaa Nipple Shield
The Haakaa Nipple Shield is designed for transitioning from bottle to breast, with a symmetrical shape and anti-slip features. Its silicone material and unique design help make the transition smoother for babies. The shield fits all nipple sizes and is dishwasher-safe, but it can be more expensive and has some texture that might confuse some babies.
6. Haakaa Silicone Nipple Shield
Especially suited for shorter or smaller nipples, the Haakaa Silicone Nipple Shield measures 15 mm and has a more traditional shape. Its thin, soft silicone and curved top allow for skin contact. This shield is dishwasher-safe, making it easy to clean.
7. Haakaa Inverted Nipple Correctors
For mothers with flat or inverted nipples, the Haakaa Inverted Nipple Correctors are designed to draw the nipples out before feedings. These nipple aspirators use suction to help with milk flow and attachment. They are available in pairs, dishwasher-safe, and come with a carrying case.
Choosing the right nipple shield depends on factors such as nipple size, shape, and any specific breastfeeding challenges. Consulting a lactation consultant can help determine the best shield and ensure proper usage. Remember, nipple shields are meant to be temporary solutions, and it's essential to have a plan to wean your baby off them once the initial issues are resolved.
Using a nipple shield correctly involves selecting the right size, applying it with warm water or nipple cream for adhesion, and ensuring a proper latch. Signs of a successful feeding include a satisfied baby, audible swallowing, and adequate urine output. Always consult with an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC) for guidance on when and how to use a nipple shield, as well as a plan to wean your baby from it.
