aluminum sesquichlorohydrate vs aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex
when comparing the effects of aluminum sesquichlorohydrate and aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex on armpits, numerous factors come into play, including skin types, sensitivity, and personal preferences. in this article, we delve into the research and findings of various studies to help determine which aluminum compound is more suitable for your needs.
aluminum sesquichlorohydrate (AS)
aluminum sesquichlorohydrate is an inorganic polymer that forms large polyaluminum complexes. this compound is known for its lower tendency to irritate the skin compared to other aluminum salts. AS is particularly effective in controlling underarm hyperhidrosis thanks to its ability to plug sweat ducts. it is typically used in over-the-counter (otc) products, with varying concentrations applied directly to the affected area.
** pros:**
- less irritating than some other aluminum salts
- highly effective for controlling underarm sweat
- can be effectively absorbed by the skin
- often used in otc antiperspirants
** cons:**
- may not be suitable for people with sensitive skin
- can leave a white residue on the skin's surface
aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex (AZT)
aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex is an inorganic compound that forms colloidal plugs in the sweat glands. this compound provides medium to long-lasting axillary hyperhidrosis control when applied directly to the skin.
** pros:**
- effective against moderate to severe hyperhidrosis
- can prevent sweat from reaching the skin's surface, reducing body odor
- provides a physical barrier against sweat
** cons:**
- can be more irritating than aluminum sesquichlorohydrate, particularly on sensitive skin
- can leave a visible white residue on the skin
study findings
several studies have been conducted to compare the effectiveness and tolerability of AS and AZT in the treatment of axillary hyperhidrosis. one study published in 2020 found that both aluminum sesquichlorohydrate and aluminum chloride were equally effective in controlling axillary hyperhidrosis. the study's authors noted that while there was no statistically significant difference between the two treatments, the study's results suggest that AS may be a viable alternative to AZT for many users.
another study published in 2008 compared the efficacy and tolerability of aluminum sesquichlorohydrate and aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex in treating hyperhidrosis. the results of this study indicate that while both compounds were effective, AZT may provide a slightly longer duration of control. the study's authors concluded that while both are suitable for over-the-counter use, AZT may be preferred by those seeking a longer duration of effect.
other Factors to Consider
- skin sensitivity and irritation to aluminum-based products
- individual preferences and preferences for the aesthetic appearance of the product
- potential interactions with other health conditions or medications
- the cost of products and their availability
conclusion
aluminum sesquichlorohydrate and aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex are both effective in controlling axillary hyperhidrosis. while there is no clear-cut winner between the two compounds, the choice ultimately depends on a person's individual needs and preferences. it's worth noting that many modern products combine both aluminum sesquichlorohydrate and aluminum zirconium tetrachlorohydrex to achieve a dual act of controlling both axillary and body odor.
